Fine of 30 Times the Minimum Wage for Undeclared Employees: Under What Conditions Is a Violation Considered Repeated?

03/11/2026

Allowing employees to perform work without properly formalizing their employment relationships may result in substantial financial penalties for employers. The consequences are particularly severe when such violations are identified repeatedly, as the amount of the fine increases significantly in these cases. At the same time, certain issues remain subject to debate in practice, including the criteria for determining whether a violation is repeated, distinguishing employment relationships from civil-law relationships, and the admissibility and sufficiency of evidence collected during inspections.

In its Resolution of 17 June 2026 in Case No. 160/31220/24, the Supreme Court considered a case concerning the legality of imposing a fine of UAH 3,360,000 on a company for repeatedly engaging 14 individuals without properly formalizing their employment relationships. Following its review, the Court concluded that the key condition for establishing a repeated violation is that the initial violation must have been identified by the competent supervisory authority and duly documented, rather than a court decision holding the employer liable being mandatory. Furthermore, a violation is considered repeated if the same employer commits a similar violation within a two-year period, even if different individuals were engaged to perform the work.

The Court also examined in detail the distinction between employment and civil-law relationships. In particular, the mere existence of a duly executed civil-law agreement does not rule out the existence of an employment relationship if, in practice, an individual performs specific job duties, is subject to the employer's organizational control, and regularly receives remuneration for their work. At the same time, the fact that an individual was allowed to work without proper formalization may be established based on a combination of evidence, including video recordings made during the inspection, explanations provided by the individuals involved, and documents confirming how the work process was organized.

In addition, the Supreme Court emphasized that failure to comply with certain procedural requirements during an inspection does not, in itself, automatically render the imposed fine unlawful. When assessing such violations, their nature and materiality must be taken into account, as well as the extent to which they restrict the employer's ability to exercise its right to defense. Accordingly, when considering disputes of this category, courts must comprehensively examine the actual nature of the relationships between the parties, the circumstances under which the repeated nature of the violation was established, the sufficiency of the evidence, and the supervisory authority's compliance with the procedure prescribed by law.

About SCHNEIDER GROUP

Since 2006 SCHNEIDER GROUP has been supporting international companies expanding to Ukraine. Our portfolio includes a full scope of services: from market analysis and partner search to complete accounting outsourcing, legal and tax consulting, and interim management services. We take over all non-core business functions so that our clients can focus on developing their business. We help our clients establishing subsidiaries in Ukraine compliant with local legislative requirements and transparent for international management. Our experts offer advice on best practices to optimise processes, reduce risks and minimise costs.

Ready to start? – Get in touch!
loading captcha...
Sending...